Financial Advice Blog

How to make the most of your employee share scheme

Employee share schemes have many benefits, but making the most of them requires a clear understanding of its types, risks, and tax implications.

Employee share schemes (ESS) serve as powerful employee incentives, encouraging a company’s employees to stay committed and align their interests with their company’s growth. However, navigating the intricacies of employee share schemes requires a clear understanding of its types, risks, and tax implications. In this article, we’ll delve into the nuances of ESS, offering insights and strategies to ensure you make the most of this valuable benefit.

Types of employee share schemes

There are three main types of employee share schemes:

  1. Employee share purchase plans (ESPP): Employees can purchase company shares at a discounted rate, often via payroll deductions.
  2. Employee share option plans (ESOP): ESOPs grant employees the option to buy company shares at a predetermined price in the future, potentially reaping profits if share prices surge.
  3. Restricted stock unit plans (RSUP): RSUPs grant employees a specified number of company shares, subject to conditions like vesting periods.

Understanding these variations and their tax treatment is essential for leveraging the benefits of employee share schemes effectively.

Navigating tax implications of employee share schemes

The tax landscape of employee share schemes is multifaceted, with implications varying based on scheme type and individual circumstances:

  • Taxed-upfront: Shares acquired at a discount or for free are considered income and taxed at the employee’s marginal rate. This is the most common tax treatment and can result in significant tax liabilities if not anticipated.
  • Tax-deferred: Some employee share scheme arrangements allow employees to delay tax payments until they sell their shares, providing a measure of flexibility.
  • Start-up concession scheme: Start-up companies may offer tax concessions to employees, promoting investment in emerging ventures.

Understanding and planning for tax implications is crucial to avoid unexpected financial burdens and cash flow issues down the line.

Mitigating risks and maximizing returns of employee share schemes

Employee share schemes present both opportunities and risks, necessitating careful consideration and strategic planning. To make the most of your employee share scheme and mitigate risk, it’s important to diversify your investment portfolio and engage in proactive tax planning.

Diversifying your investment portfolio

Employees that participate in employee share schemes they may amass a significant number of shares from their employer, potentially reaching into the millions over time. However, relying excessively on a single stock acquired through employee share schemes exposes individuals to heightened risk.

To counteract this risk, it’s imperative to craft a diversified investment portfolio across various stocks and asset classes. This spreads risk and fortifies your investments against market fluctuations.

Proactive tax planning

Employees are often caught out at tax time, particularly when shares are offered ‘for free’ or ‘at a discount. Failure to plan ahead can lead to substantial tax bills, potentially straining cash flow. For example, if an employee in the 39% tax bracket receives shares valued at $10,000 ‘for free’, they could face a tax bill of $3,900. Assuming they hold them and haven’t realised any gains from selling, they’ll need to find money from other sources to foot the tax bill.

Further, the tax treatment of vested shares under restricted stock unit plans (RSUP) introduces additional complexities. Whether employees hold onto the shares, sell them immediately, or wait for a certain period after vesting, tax implications vary. Without early tax planning, individuals may find themselves facing significant tax bills upon share vesting, irrespective of their selling decisions.

Additionally, market volatility poses a substantial risk, and in extreme cases, the value of shares could plummet below the tax owed, leaving individuals in a precarious financial situation. This was seen in the aftermath of the dot-com bubble burst. Many tech stocks saw their prices tumble by more than 50% as the NASQAC dropped by 78% from peak to trough. For someone in the top tax bracket with $10,000 worth of shares vested near the peak, only to see their value drop in value to $2,500 months later, wouldn’t have enough to cover their $4,900 tax bill. This is obviously an extreme example, but demonstrates you are exposed to both the upside and downside of market risk when you acquire shares through employee share schemes.

By anticipating potential tax implications, individuals can make informed decisions, ensuring financial stability and no nasty surprises at tax time.

Harness the benefits of your employee share scheme

Employee share schemes offer compelling benefits but require careful planning and consideration to maximise returns and minimise risks. By understanding the nuances of employee share schemes, diversifying your financial strategy and navigating tax implications, you can harness the full potential of this valuable benefit. At Financial Spectrum, we specialise in employee share scheme planning and optimisation. Contact us today to ensure you’re making the most of your employee share scheme.

Share this article


More articles

Talk to us, guaranteed value

We’re so confident about creating value for you quickly, that we guarantee it with a 100% money-back guarantee.

Book a complimentary financial strategy session.